Home › Answered Needs › Fine, fine, fine, NOT FINE: when grief comes and goes

Fine, fine, fine, NOT FINE: when grief comes and goes

Someone wrote on Bluesky: “Since my dad died, my grief has felt like windshield wipers set to intermittent. Fine fine fine fine NOT FINE fine fine fine fine NOT FINE fine.”

The capital letters do what grief does. Four quiet beats, then one that fills the whole line. Then quiet again, as if nothing happened.

If your grief keeps arriving like that, in between stretches where you really are fine, this is for you.

Fine is not finished

The rhythm makes it easy to treat two things as one: being fine and being finished.

Four “fine”s in a row can start to sound like a verdict: through it. Then NOT FINE arrives, and it can feel like the verdict was overturned, as if the fine stretches were a pretense and the grief had been waiting the whole time to prove it.

The post doesn’t say that. It counts the fine beats one by one, nine of them, right alongside the two that weren’t. Neither kind cancels the other.

Fine is a report on this moment. Finished would be a claim about every moment still to come. The post makes the first and never makes the second.

The loss, or the feeling of it?

The image holds a second distinction. Wipers set to intermittent don’t mean the rain has stopped. They mean the glass has time to clear between passes.

The loss is like the rain. It doesn’t come and go. The dad who died is just as gone during the fine beats as during the NOT FINE ones. What comes and goes is the feeling of it: the moment the glass fills and has to be cleared.

So a NOT FINE beat isn’t the loss getting bigger, or progress sliding backward. It’s the same loss, felt again. And a fine beat isn’t forgetting him. It’s the same loss, quiet for a moment.

From the book

In Reality Is Your Friend, Levi M. Johnson draws this same line between what changes inside us and what doesn’t:

What is subjective about your feelings is that they change, and they do not stay the same. Simultaneously it is objectively true that your feelings exist, and are valid. It is not true that you will always feel happy, but it is true that you feel and will continue to feel whether you want to or not.

Next to the post, the fine and the NOT FINE are both the part that changes. Neither one stays. Underneath both is the part that doesn’t change: the feelings exist, they are valid, and they keep coming because the loss is real.

Going deeper

Elsewhere in the same book he writes that

…the Kingdom of Heaven, or the fabric of Reality as we notice it and interact with it and even partner with, only supplies us with what we need now, now, and now.

Now, now, and now is the same rhythm as fine, fine, fine. Grief arrives one beat at a time, and so, he writes, does what is needed.

Fine is not finished. The loss is not the feeling of it. The post already holds both: nine honest “fine”s and two honest NOT FINEs.

If one distinction helped, the book stays with feelings that change and the reality underneath them that doesn’t: Reality Is Your Friend · Buy the ebook with Bitcoin (Lightning) → · Browse the books →

This page is part of answered needs at FikaTimeBooks.com — real questions, real answers, no squeeze.

Also on truth: It's the first birthday without him · The valley of tears · Feeling extremely overwhelmed is the easiest way I will break · More in Truth: Granular Insights