Home › Granular Insights › Intelligence › Intelligence is NOT Fixed
Intelligence is NOT Fixed
Some people mistakenly think that intelligence is fixed because of genetics, but others correctly believe that intelligence is not fixed, according to Salman Khan of Khanacademy.com, an online learning website which boasts millions of unique visits per month. In his article The Learning Myth: Why I’ll Never Tell My Son He’s Smart, Khan explains, “Researchers have known for some time that the brain is like a muscle; that the more you use it, the more it grows. They’ve found that neural connections form and deepen when we make mistakes doing difficult tasks rather than repeatedly having success with easy ones.”
Khan goes on to praise “growth mindset interventions”, in which one’s process of learning is affirmed, rather than praising “traits or talent.” This might sound like, “Good job on working hard on that problem”, rather than saying, “You’re so smart!”
In my analysis of this article against my teaching and language learning experience, it rings true. The following story will act as anecdotal evidence.
In January of 2014 I began Master of Arts studies in TESOL. As I began my coursework, I felt as if my chest was going to explode. Every word I read seemed like a foreign language and I struggled intensely to understand the academic speak of my course books. I struggled even harder with writing papers since my professor used a level of scrutiny I did not experience with my undergraduate papers. Then, slowly, my brain started catching up with the coursework, and now eight months into my coursework my mind is far sharper than it was prior to starting the program. Just a couple of weeks ago I scored in the top 1% of highest IQ’s in the country, whereas before I had immense trouble even finishing the practice test to become a member of MENSA. I attribute this rise in personal intelligence to the challenge of my coursework and professors, and how hard I have had to think about linguistics and language teaching in order to produce quality papers.
Discovering concrete evidence that intelligence is not fixed, and furthermore discovering that there are techniques which I can use to spur my students to grow in their intelligence level in combination with English language proficiency, is greatly encouraging to me. This reminder of proper techniques to use with my students to encourage growth has come at the exact right time.
I’ve noticed that one of my students has been growing discouraged during her language exercises. I’ve tried to encourage her by telling her, “you are so smart! Look at the progress that you’ve made”, but ironically, despite my efforts, she has been losing heart. Now after having read Sal’s article, I realize that telling her how smart she is is exactly the wrong thing to do. I need to be commending her process. I need to be commending how hard she is working. I need to be encouraging her about the level of effort she’s been investing, and the struggles and mistakes she endures each time I push her to express with mastery what I have taught her. Now it is becoming clear to me how I might encourage her. And not only her but the rest of my students for the remainder of my life in order to foster a growth mindset. As Sal points out in his article, “If society as a whole begins to embrace the struggle of learning, there is no end to what that could mean for global human potential.”
Opportunities for Growth
Do you agree or disagree with Salman Khan’s assertions and my anecdotal evidence? Why or why not?
Do you believe intelligence is fixed by genetics, or malleable based upon the extent of struggle, mistakes, resulting in achievement?
How can you perform “growth mindset interventions” with those in your circles of influence?
What do you think the world would look like if we praised and affirmed others’ tenacity and perseverance in the face of struggles and mistakes on the path to accomplishment?
Would these actions cause it to be a better or worse place?
Trade your email for the Introduction and Chapter 1 of the book you choose.
You'll receive the Introduction and Chapter 1 of the book you choose, plus occasional emails from FikaTimeBooks.com. Unsubscribe anytime. We never share your email.
Also on intelligence: How do I become more intelligent? · I’m so slow in comparison · Slowing down, not stopping · More in Intelligence: Granular Insights